Sbw

[Teegy]

I don't know what other think but Sonny-Bill Williams is highly overated. will be a good player but has to get onto the field to prove how good he is.

[Dakink]

I don't know what other think but Sonny-Bill Williams is highly overated. will be a good player but has to get onto the field to prove how good he is.

Not sure if he is over rated as such. Did some amazing things when he was on the field. Over paid perhaps but his untalent is undeniable. Needs to get more game time to prove his worth in dollar value.

[Teegy]

Without a doubt he is good but i have heard people call him the 3 best player in the world :confused:

[Mitch]

Ok.
1. He is overpaid.
2. He is injury prone :(.
3. He is a **** GUN!
4. I Cant wait till he back 2 full fitness.
5. He aint over-rated.

[Cliffy GC]

hes a very good player
we are too quick to say someone is great now days

We will know whos great in 7 and 8 seasons time if he has continued to produce the form he did 2004

[Teegy]

too Right Cliffy i think he has to prove himself

[Super Cronk]

i think he is extremely over-rated.

He has some skill sure...a good off-load and a good shoulder charge. Thats about it tho. He is injury prone at an early age which is never good.

He is hailed as some really good player but i think he is just a kid with alot of potential.

[DeeGan]

Sonny-Bill Williams, what a talent first of all!

Sonny-Bill Williams is not a great player, he is a young up and coming super star who has the potential to become a modern day great though he will need to keep himself on the field to be able to achieve that tag.

When on the field, the glimpses of greatness are there for all to see, look no further than any appearance in the NZ test jersey for proof or as recent as the Round clash vs St George Illawarra where he was unstoppable in setting the Doggies win.

The 'great' tag is used all too loosely in the modern era where it seems any player who is quick to show any class is labelled as such by the media in order to sell their paper or magazine.

Let the kid grow into the enormous potential we have already seen. With Benji, Karmichael and Tim Smith, the future of the NRL is in safe hands.

[footyfan09]

Good Player but defiantly overated a bit

[Shadow XL]

we need to see more of him as you have said, but last year he was good, more on field time needed.

[PARANoIR]

Over rated. Over paid. Over injured. And Im a Dogs supporter.

Hell, I can last 2 minutes on a football field...give me 400 grand a year!